Blog

How Do You Value a Family Business for a Sale, Gift, or Succession?

Short answer: A family business valuation puts a written value on a family company for one purpose, such as a sale, a gift, or an estate return. Cooper Norman values family businesses in Idaho and Utah. First, write down who will read the number.

Family pay is often set when a child joins the business, then left alone for years. In the books it reads like any other wage. A valuation prices that work as if the company had to hire for it. That restated wage can put the price above or below what the books suggest, years later, when the child buys the parents’ shares.

Which tax rules apply in Idaho and Utah?

Federal ones. Neither Idaho nor Utah has a current estate or inheritance tax, so the rules that test a family business value for gifts and estates come from the IRS (see the questions at the end).

Farms and ranches get their own section below, because land and family labor change the math. For the service itself, see business valuation in Idaho and Utah.

What makes a family business harder to value?

Years of shared work make it hard to see the business the way an outside buyer would. Some owners price in the history. Others look only at this year’s income and miss the land, the equipment, or the customer list.

Three things come up often: personal costs paid by the business, family members paid above or below market, and land or equipment the business owns but does not need to operate. Each one moves the value, and each one can start an argument between siblings if nobody has written it down.

A written valuation takes those items one at a time and shows how each one changes the number.

How is a family business valued, step by step?

  1. Set the purpose and the standard of value. A gift or an estate uses fair market value. A buy-sell agreement may name its own price method.
  2. Normalize the books. Take out personal costs, restate family pay at market rates, and set aside land or equipment the business does not need to operate.
  3. Apply the approaches. Weigh the income, market and asset-based approaches, the three the IRS calls generally accepted.
  4. Adjust for the share being valued. A minority share may take a discount for lack of control or lack of marketability.
  5. Reconcile and report. Combine the results into one conclusion and document the method, the data and the reasoning, so a buyer, a sibling or the IRS can follow it.

Which family adjustments change the value?

A valuator adjusts the books to show what the business would earn under any owner. These terms show up in the report:

  • Normalized earnings. Profit with one-time, personal and unusual items taken out. Personal costs paid by the company come out here.
  • Owner and family pay. Wages for relatives are restated at what the work would cost at market rates. Unpaid family labor makes profit look higher than it is, and above-market family salaries make it look lower.
  • Minority interest. An ownership share of less than 50% of the voting interest.
  • Discount for lack of control. A reduction for a share that cannot direct how the company is run.
  • Discount for lack of marketability. A reduction for a share that cannot be sold quickly or easily.
  • Fair market value. The price a willing buyer and a willing seller would agree on, when neither is forced to act and both know the relevant facts. Federal gift and estate tax returns use this standard.

Why use an outside valuator?

An outside valuator has no stake in the number, and the people who test it can trace how it was reached. For gifts reported on a gift tax return, IRS disclosure rules also limit who can do the appraisal (see the questions at the end).

You will usually need one for a sale, a transfer to family members, an estate plan, a divorce, or a tax filing.

At Cooper Norman, each report names its purpose and its standard of value first, so the reader knows what the number is for.

How would you value a family farm?

Picture a farm that has run for several generations. The land has gained value, the equipment has been upgraded, and several family members work the operation. The parents want to retire, sell the farm to the child who works it, and treat their other children fairly.

A fair price is hard to set without an agricultural business valuation. Land values on the books may be decades old. Book depreciation rarely matches what the equipment would sell for. Income swings with weather and commodity prices, and unpaid family labor makes profit look higher than it is.

The valuation weighs the land, equipment, livestock, operating income, and market conditions together, so the whole family works from one number everyone has seen. This example is illustrative. It is not a client story.

What changes when the business is a farm or ranch?

A farm or ranch valuation has to account for land productivity, seasonal cash flow, commodity prices, and long-term asset value.

For many farm families, the valuation is the first step in a succession or estate plan. The valuator has to weigh what the operation earns against what the land and equipment would bring on their own.

If the farm is also part of an estate plan, see our guide to estate tax planning for Idaho farm families.

When should you value a family business?

Before a sale, and at other points too: retirement planning, adding or removing a partner, an estate plan, or a loan application. A current value also shows the gap between what the business is worth today and what you need it to be worth when you leave.

A value done while the exit is still years away leaves time to act on what it shows.

A family business valuation starts with why you need the number. A sale, a transfer to a son or daughter, a buy-sell agreement and a tax filing each put the value in front of a different reader. That reader might be a buyer, a lender, a family member or the IRS. Cooper Norman’s business valuation team, led by Jordan Graves, CPA, ABV, CFF, builds the value for the reader who will test it.

Which federal tax rules apply to each family transfer?

Federal tax rules set what the IRS expects when family business shares change hands by gift, at death or under a buy-sell agreement.

Family transferTax return that uses the valueFederal rule to know
Gift of shares to childrenGift tax return (Form 709)If an appraisal is submitted in place of the valuation-method details, the appraiser cannot be the giver, the receiver, a member of either family or an employee of any of them.
Shares passing at deathEstate tax return (Form 706)For closely held shares, the value weighs net worth, earning power, dividend-paying capacity and goodwill, and the financial data behind it should go with the return.
Buy-sell price among relativesGift or estate tax returnThe agreement price counts only if it is a bona fide business arrangement, isn’t a device to pass value to family for less, and is comparable to arm’s length deals.
Sources: 26 CFR 301.6501(c)-1(f), 26 CFR 20.2031-2, 26 CFR 25.2703-1, IRS Form 706.

What should you gather first?

Recent financial statements and tax returns, any buy-sell agreement, and a list of land and equipment the business holds. Bring those, and the reason you need the value, to a first conversation with our valuation team.

Frequently asked questions

Do Idaho or Utah have their own estate or inheritance tax?

No current one in either state. The Idaho State Tax Commission says Idaho has no gift tax or inheritance tax, and its estate tax for deaths expired in 2004. The Utah State Tax Commission says Utah’s inheritance tax ended after December 31, 2004, and Utah inheritance tax returns do not need to be filed. Federal rules still apply. For 2026, the IRS lists the estate tax basic exclusion amount as $15,000,000 and the gift tax annual exclusion as $19,000 per recipient. Both limits are counted in dollars, so the value of the shares decides how much of each limit a transfer uses.

How long can the IRS question the value of gifted family business shares?

How long the IRS can question the value of gifted family business shares depends on disclosure. In general, tax must be assessed within 3 years after the return is filed (26 CFR 301.6501(a)-1), and adequate disclosure of the gift on a gift tax return (Form 709) starts that clock. Without adequate disclosure, the IRS can assess gift tax on the gift at any time (26 CFR 301.6501(c)-1(f)). For shares in a family company, an appraisal submitted with the return can take the place of the detailed description of the valuation method that disclosure requires. The return still has to describe the shares and name the giver, each receiver and how they are related. The appraisal must state the gift date, the appraisal date, the purpose, the method and the financial data behind the value, in enough detail that another person could repeat the work.

Who can appraise shares given to family members?

When an appraisal is submitted with a gift tax return in place of a detailed description of the valuation method, IRS rules say the appraiser must pass three tests. The appraiser offers appraisals to the public or does them regularly. The appraiser’s background and experience fit the kind of property. And the appraiser is not the giver, the receiver, a member of either family, or anyone they employ. At Cooper Norman, Matthew Barker, CPA, CVA, puts the valuation and the tax result in the same conversation.

Can a buy-sell agreement set the value of family shares for estate tax?

Only if it passes three separate federal tests. For agreements made or substantially changed after October 8, 1990, the price counts for estate and gift tax only when the agreement is a bona fide business arrangement, is not a device to pass the business to family for less than full value, and has terms comparable to deals made at arm’s length. If it fails, the IRS values the shares without regard to the agreement price (26 CFR 25.2703-1; the 1990 date is in 26 CFR 25.2703-2). Your attorney drafts the agreement. A valuation can test the buy-sell price method before anyone signs.

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice for a specific situation.

Back to the Journal

Newsletter

Practical owner guidance, monthly.

Tax, transition, and decision insights from the Cooper Norman team.