Blog

Key Vs. Non-Key Controls in Auditing

Short answer: A key control is a check that addresses a risk of material misstatement, which the auditor identifies, evaluates and, when needed, tests. Non-key controls support the same process, but one failing alone is unlikely to cause a material misstatement.

If you’re in business, especially running or managing finances, the terms “key controls” and “non-key controls” might sound technical, but understanding them is simpler than you think. At Cooper Norman, we believe in making auditing straightforward and helping our clients protect their businesses from unnecessary risks. Let’s break down the basics of key and non-key controls and why they’re essential in auditing.

What Are Key and Non-Key Controls?

In auditing, controls are safeguards or “checks” put in place to ensure that a company’s financial processes are reliable and accurate. Think of them as steps that make certain tasks are done right and that any errors or risks are caught before they become big issues.

  1. Key Controls: These are the most important. Key controls are designed to tackle significant financial risks head-on. In other words, if a key control fails, there’s a high chance that something serious could go wrong, like a material misstatement in your financial records. Auditors focus closely on key controls because these are the “must-haves” to keep finances accurate and compliant.
  2. Non-Key Controls: These controls are also helpful but not essential for addressing major financial risks. Non-key controls add a layer of support but don’t directly impact the biggest risks to the company’s financial reporting. While still important, non-key controls don’t have as much impact if they fail because they aren’t tackling those high-stakes areas.

What terms do auditors use for controls?

  • Internal control over financial reporting (ICFR): the checks that owners, managers, and staff use to keep the financial statements reliable.
  • Five components of internal control: the control environment, the risk assessment process, the information system and communication, control activities, and monitoring of controls.
  • Key control: AICPA auditing standards say the controls auditors must identify in the control activities component “are sometimes referred to by auditors as relevant controls or key controls.”
  • Test of controls: audit work that checks whether a control actually worked during the year, called its operating effectiveness.
  • Substantive procedure: audit work that looks for errors in the numbers directly, by testing details or by comparing amounts with what the auditor expects.
  • Preventive control: a control meant to stop an error or fraud before it causes a misstatement.
  • Detective control: a control meant to find and correct an error or fraud that already happened.
  • Significant risk: a risk of material misstatement whose inherent risk sits near the top of the auditor’s scale, or one the standards say to treat that way.

Why Do Auditors Focus More on Key Controls?

Auditors prioritize key controls during an audit because these are what safeguard a business from potentially costly or reputation-damaging errors. Here’s an example: Imagine your business processes high volumes of transactions each day. A key control here might be verifying large transactions to prevent unauthorized expenses. If this control fails, it could lead to significant financial losses. So, auditors will spend time testing this control thoroughly.

On the other hand, a non-key control could be something smaller, like checking that expense reimbursements under a certain amount are filed correctly. If this control slips, it’s not as likely to cause a major problem.

When does an auditor have to test a key control?

Under AICPA standards for private company audits (AU-C 330), the auditor must test whether controls worked in two cases:

  • The auditor plans to rely on the controls so it can do less other testing.
  • Testing the numbers directly cannot give enough evidence on its own.

If neither applies, the auditor can test the numbers directly instead, such as balances and transactions. The auditor still has to find the key controls, check their design, and confirm they are in place (AU-C 315).

How often are key controls retested?

These rules apply to controls the auditor relies on.

  • If a control changed since it was last tested, the auditor tests it in the current audit.
  • If it has not changed, the auditor can use earlier evidence but must retest it at least once in every third audit, and must test some controls in each audit.
  • Controls over a significant risk that the auditor relies on are tested in the current audit, every time.

How do auditors test a key control?

Asking staff is not enough. AU-C 330 says inquiry alone cannot show that a control worked. Auditors pair inquiry with inspection of documents, observation of the control, recalculation, or reperformance. Reperformance means redoing the control, such as reworking a bank reconciliation.

Key and Non-Key Controls in Action

Imagine you own a retail business. Here’s how key and non-key controls might work together in your financial systems:

  • Key Control Example: Approving every purchase over $1,000. This is a key control because it prevents large unauthorized expenses from slipping through. Auditors will test this to make sure there’s a strong process in place to approve these expenses.
  • Non-Key Control Example: Monitoring office supply expenses under $100. While still good practice, missing this step likely wouldn’t lead to serious financial consequences, so auditors might not focus as closely on this.

What are examples of key and non-key controls by process?

Whether a control is key depends on the auditor’s risk assessment for your business, so the same control can be key in one audit and not in another.

ProcessOften a key controlOften a non-key control
PurchasingApproval of every purchase over a set amount, such as $1,000Review of office supply spending under $100
CashMonthly bank reconciliation reviewed by someone who does not handle cash (segregation of duties)Petty cash count
PayrollReview of pay rate and new-hire changes before payroll is releasedCheck that time-off calendars match HR records
RevenueMatching invoices to delivery or service records before revenue is recordedFollow-up calls to new customers
Journal entriesReview and approval of manual journal entriesReminder emails about close deadlines
Illustrations, not a list from the auditing standards. The standards do require auditors to identify controls over journal entries.

What happens when a key control fails?

The auditor decides how serious the gap is. AU-C 265 uses three levels:

LevelWhat it meansWho hears about it
DeficiencyThe control’s design or operation does not let staff prevent, or find and fix, errors on timeManagement, in writing or orally, when the auditor judges it important enough
Significant deficiencyLess serious than a material weakness, but important enough for those charged with governance, such as owners or a board, to hear aboutThose charged with governance and management, in writing
Material weaknessA reasonable possibility that a material error will not be prevented, or found and fixed, on timeThose charged with governance and management, in writing
Source: AICPA AU-C 265.07, .11, and .12.

Significant deficiencies and material weaknesses are reported even if you fixed them during the audit.

Does a service provider’s SOC report change your key controls?

It can. If a payroll or billing provider, called a service organization, gives you a SOC report on its controls, read the section on complementary user entity controls. These are checks the provider assumes you do yourself, such as reviewing the reports it sends you. If the provider’s control goals depend on them, they are part of your own controls and may be key.

How Cooper Norman Helps You Manage Controls

AICPA auditing standards start from the premise that management is responsible for designing, putting in place, and maintaining internal control. An audit does not take over that job. Cooper Norman writes audit findings your bank and board can act on. If you want your controls studied on their own, ask about an internal control study, which is scoped separately from the audit.

Why This Matters for Your Business

When key and non-key controls are balanced effectively, your financial systems can handle day-to-day operations more smoothly, and you’ll be better protected from unexpected risks. Whether you’re a small business or a larger operation, understanding these controls makes it easier to see where potential issues might arise and gives you peace of mind that the foundation is strong.

Frequently asked questions

What is a key control in auditing?

A key control is a check the auditor singles out because it guards against a risk of material misstatement, such as approval of large purchases or review of manual journal entries. AICPA auditing standards note that auditors sometimes call these relevant controls or key controls.

What is the difference between key and non-key controls?

A key control guards against a risk that could cause a material error, so the auditor evaluates it and may test it. A non-key control supports the process, but if it failed alone, a material error would be unlikely. The auditor usually spends less time on it.

Does every audit test key controls?

No. Under AU-C 330, the auditor must test whether controls worked only when it plans to rely on them, or when testing the numbers directly cannot give enough evidence. Otherwise the auditor may test balances and transactions directly. It still checks the design of key controls and confirms they are in place.

How often must an auditor retest a key control?

For a control the auditor relies on, at least once in every third audit if it has not changed, with some controls tested in each audit. Relied-on controls that changed, and relied-on controls over significant risks, are tested in the current audit.

Is asking employees enough to test a control?

No. AU-C 330 says inquiry alone cannot show that a control worked. Auditors pair questions with inspecting documents, watching the control, recalculating, or redoing the control.

What is the difference between a significant deficiency and a material weakness?

A material weakness means there is a reasonable possibility that a material error will not be prevented, or found and fixed, on time. A significant deficiency is less serious, but still important enough for owners or a board to hear about. The auditor reports both in writing.

How is a review different from an audit?

A review uses inquiry and analytical procedures and gives limited assurance. An audit tests balances and transactions, looks at internal controls, and ends with an opinion. It gives reasonable assurance, a high but not absolute level. If a lender or surety asked for one, send Cooper Norman the request letter and the team will tell you which level answers it.

Does Cooper Norman study internal controls outside an audit?

Yes. Internal control studies are a specialty service of Cooper Norman’s audit and assurance team, scoped separately from compilation, review, and audit engagements. Thomas Ryan, CPA, MACC, leads audit and assurance.

Sources checked November 5, 2026:

Have questions about key controls in auditing for your business? Cooper Norman’s audit and assurance team starts with who needs your statements and why, then tests what that level of assurance requires. Send us the request, and we will tell you what the engagement involves.

Back to the Journal

Newsletter

Practical owner guidance, monthly.

Tax, transition, and decision insights from the Cooper Norman team.