Blog

Employee or Independent Contractor? An Update for Construction Businesses

The construction industry is no stranger to independent contractors. One advantage of using contract workers is that they are generally not subject to the federal wage and hour requirements largely enforced by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL).

However, the DOL also regulates whether a worker should be classified as an employee rather than an independent contractor. The agency’s test for making that call has changed repeatedly in recent years, causing understandable concern and confusion for many construction business owners. Here is where things stand.

Where the DOL rule stands

In 2024, the DOL under the Biden administration generally took a “totality of the circumstances” approach to the employee-or-independent-contractor question. It looked at six factors to determine a worker’s status, with no single factor weighing more heavily than another. Like previous DOL rules in this area, the 2024 rule applied only to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).

In May 2025, the DOL under the Trump administration directed its investigators to stop applying the 2024 rule in enforcement investigations. That action did not rescind the rule, and it did not prevent courts, or workers suing employers, from applying it.

In February 2026, the DOL issued a proposed rule that would rescind and replace the 2024 guidance. The proposal would apply its worker classification test not only to the FLSA but also to the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection Act.

On October 28, 2026, the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs completed its final review of the proposed rule, which is generally considered more business friendly. As of this writing, however, the DOL had not yet published it.

How the proposed rule classifies workers

The proposed rule looks at the “economic reality” of the relationship: whether the worker is economically dependent on the business for work or is in business for themselves. The analysis would focus on two core factors:

  1. The nature and degree of the worker’s control over the work
  2. The individual’s opportunity for profit or loss based on initiative or investment

Notably, requiring workers to meet legal, health and safety, or typical business-to-business contractual standards would not indicate the type of control that suggests employee status. Nor would requiring a worker to carry insurance.

The proposed rule identifies three additional factors that are relevant, particularly when the core factors do not point to the same conclusion:

  1. The amount of skill required for the work
  2. The permanence of the working relationship between the worker and the business
  3. Whether the work is part of an integrated unit of production

Other factors could be considered if they are relevant to determining the worker’s economic independence.

The preamble to the proposed rule makes clear that when both core factors point to the same classification, the other factors will rarely outweigh them. The current DOL has also indicated that “actual practice” is more relevant to its analysis than what may be contractually or theoretically possible.

For example, a contract worker might theoretically be free to set prices or take jobs from other businesses. But if the business engaging that independent contractor restricts the individual from doing those things, that freedom is less meaningful. By the same token, a contract might allow the business to supervise or discipline the worker, but that provision matters less if the business never uses that authority.

Why the DOL rule is not the whole picture

If your construction business engages independent contractors, a less restrictive DOL rule might tempt you to relax your compliance efforts. That is not a good idea, for several reasons. For starters, the IRS and the National Labor Relations Board may apply different standards to the employee-versus-independent-contractor question.

Some states also have their own tests, which can be stricter than the DOL’s rule. California, New Jersey and several others, for example, apply a three-prong test for wage and hour laws. States may use different tests for workers’ compensation, unemployment insurance and payroll taxes, so contractors working in Idaho and Utah should check each state’s rules as well as the federal ones.

Courts are not necessarily bound by the DOL’s interpretation of federal law either, and many jurisdictions have developed their own multifactor tests for worker classification. The bottom line: complying only with the DOL rule will not necessarily keep you in compliance with your other obligations.

Review your worker classifications now

Think of the DOL’s proposed rule as a friendly reminder. It is a good idea to regularly re-evaluate how your construction business classifies workers so you stay compliant with all applicable standards. If HR and payroll compliance is stretching your team thin, it may also be worth asking whether a PEO could help, and if you work on federal projects, Davis-Bacon Act compliance adds another layer of wage rules.

Your attorney can help you work through the legal details. Cooper Norman works with contractors across Idaho and Utah on the payroll tax side of this question. Contact us to assess the payroll tax implications and potential financial risks of how your workers are classified.

Back to the Journal

Newsletter

Practical owner guidance, monthly.

Tax, transition, and decision insights from the Cooper Norman team.